Delving into the Flight Attendants’ Service Concerns
In a recent move, American Airlines decided to amp up its economy service game on select flights. They’re bringing back a second round of drink service in economy on domestic flights traveling over 1,500 miles. Plus, for those long haul international flights taking off before the stroke of 9:01 PM, there’s a promise of pre-dinner drinks for economy passengers. Sounds like a step up, right?
Hold your applause! Despite this seemingly upgraded service, the Association of Professional Flight Attendants (APFA), representing roughly 28,000 of American’s crew, isn’t toasting to this news. They’ve got some bones to pick, as flagged by an industry insider on social media. Let’s zoom in on whether there’s substance in their gripes.
The Union’s Critique of Management Moves
The union isn’t exactly thrilled with the company upping service levels without inviting them to the discussion table first. They also allege that management might be pulling a fast one on them. Time to get to the bottom of it.
Flashback to the onset of the pandemic: American Airlines, citing decreased demand, trimmed down staffing on some flights. As the skies got busier, they opted not to boost those numbers back. Instead, they suggested a new norm of reduced service was here to stay. Now, they’re totally flipping the script.
During negotiations over reduced staffing, union reps were assured by the airline’s inflight service leadership that there were no plans to revert to pre-COVID service protocols, dubbing the ‘temporary’ as the new ‘permanent’.
This thinly masked promise feels like a slap not just to flight attendants but to passengers too. With no extra catering onboard and no additional crew to manage this service, we’re all set up for frustration. Management’s about-face reveals that their arguments were not about what was operationally feasible — they were about pinching pennies at the expense of crews and customers alike.
American Airlines keeps pushing for more work from fewer flight attendants while masquerading under the guise of “enhancing the customer experience.” The onboard product is falling behind rivals in every cabin and yes, even Wall Street has noticed. The bleak financial reports for the first quarter of 2025 are sounding alarms about the lack of investment in the inflight experience taking a toll on the brand and the bottom line.
My Take on the Recent Unrest
Let’s assess the situation rationally. Rather than defaulting to stereotypes about lazy flight attendants or demonizing unions, let’s weigh the union’s points. While some concerns seem valid, there’s a touch of melodrama in others, unless I’m missing something.
If American’s rolling out more drink services without adding supplies, that’s problematic. The union has a point if passengers get short-changed on their second round of drinks. It’s crucial they resolve this.
On the staffing front, I’m puzzled. When COVID hit, American cut staffing on numerous aircraft — say, the 777-300ERs dropped from 13 to 11 crew members. The domestic fleets like the 737s didn’t see any cuts as they were already at the minimum.
I’m struggling to pinpoint why specific service changes might be challenging for the crew. For example:
- Most 1,500+ mile flights are operated on aircraft that didn’t face staffing slashes.
- If attendants can manage a single drink service on a five-hour journey, a second service post-break should be manageable.
- Even post-reduction, the economy staffing level still matches or surpasses those on narrow-body aircraft.
For the pre-dinner drinks on long hauls, though, I acknowledge the challenge. It’s more about the potential for service delays leading to unhappy patrons rather than the capability of the crew. Speed can be an issue with lean staffing.
I’d love for flight attendants to enlighten us: Which service aspects present hurdles? Is it the second drinks service on long domestic hops or the pre-dinner round on international flights? Any aircraft in particular where it’s worse?
For what it’s worth, I rarely give management the benefit of the doubt. Still, let’s consider this: When the head honcho for inflight service broadcasted the finality of reduced services, I genuinely think they meant it. The mindset then was about sinking to new lows. Now, AA’s angling for upgrades — plus, the executor of that old message has moved on. I smell no foul play here.
Final Thoughts
American is trying to elevate its economy service via extra drink rounds. Yet, the flight attendant union isn’t raising their glasses. With the pandemic staffing cuts still in play, their concerns are about being misled.
While I get their skepticism over drink provisioning, I’m grappling with the claim that aspects of the shifted service are unsustainable.
What’s your take on the union’s stance against management’s recent decisions?
Meanwhile, if you’re planning a getaway, consider hopping over to the Val Seny ski resort for some snow-filled fun!